Bella Roma Pizzeria

The Top 9 Pizza Shop Recommendations in Kissimmee

pizza ingredients

While Kissimmee in Osceola County, Florida, is probably best known for its proximity to Walt Disney World, it also has beautiful lakefront parks, family-friendly adventure attractions, and… a vibrant pizza scene!

When you're on vacation, nothing beats the taste buds or the budget by heading to a pizza shop to share an enormous pie. Slices dripping with mozz are also the perfect grab-and-go lunch when you're running from attraction to attraction.

Of course, where you choose to nosh down on pizza makes all the difference to your experience. Do you want Chicago deep dish or traditional Italian fare? Plus, not all pizzerias are created equal.

To help you decide, we've put together a go-to list of the best pizza places in Kissimmee. So read on!

1. Bella Roma

Okay, so we might be a bit biased here, but we're proud of the award-winning pizzas at Bella Roma. If you're looking for authentic Italian pizza, we've got you covered!

We make all our pizza dough from scratch and use only the freshest ingredients and toppings. Dine in or takeout on pizza, salad, stromboli, lasagna, and more to experience deliciousness at your fingertips. Plus, we're vegetarian-friendly!

Bella Roma also has a mobile wood-fired oven and catering services for those hosting events.

2. Broadway Pizza Bar

When it comes to pizza places, New York has the eat-on-the-run slice down to a fine art. If you're in Kissimmee, Broadway Pizza Bar is the real deal—short of getting a plane to the Big Apple!

Aside from New York-style gourmet pizza, they also offer wraps, salads, wings, pasta, and New York-style cheesecake. Swill your meal down with a glass or two from their excellent wine menu.

And since the weather is always lovely in Florida (right?), take advantage of this restaurant's stunning patio dining.

3. Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza

If you're a bit of a pizza snob looking for an artisanal slice, head to Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza.

This Disney Springs staple has made a true art out of pizza-making. Diners can choose from well over 40 different topping options, including unique treats like the Art Lover (artichokes, mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, and red sauce) or the White Top (cream sauce, mozzarella, bacon, garlic, oregano, and arugula).

Dine in to watch your exact pizza enter the wood-fired oven raw and come out again piping hot and ready to eat in just three minutes.

4. Flippers Pizzeria Restaurants

This Kissimmee favorite is located in Old Town and offers dine-in and takeaway pizza options.

The talented chefs at Flippers craft their authentic pizzas, calzones, and sandwiches in a handbuilt brick oven. Customers praise the food for being fresh, made-to-order, and great value for money, while the service is friendly and welcoming. Try their pizzas for sure, but also consider branding out to some of the tasty, Italian-inspired salads and sides.

If you're looking for an affordable, tasty, traditional, and family-friendly dining spot, look no further than Flippers.

5. Main Street Pizza

Visitors wanting authentic Italian-American fare while in Kissimmee can expect exactly that when they visit Main Street Pizza.

The owners keep things traditional and straightforward, with a menu featuring a few options for salad, pasta, and sandwiches. The pizzas are build-your-own—you choose the size first, then the toppings (meats and vegetables)—or they have pre-arranged specialty options.

Bear in mind the whopping 36-inch monster pizza is dine-in only! It's great for a family happy to share their slices.

6. Al's Pizzeria

If you're looking for a simple slice of pie and a drink, Brooklyn style, you can't beat Al's Pizzeria. This classic locale is praised by visitors and locals alike for its tasty pizza and drinks combos at unbelievable prices.

While it might be the best place for a pizza date, it's undeniably an excellent spot for foodies on a budget. Or, if you do want a pizza date, grab some takeaway slices and a couple of cups and head down to Kissimmee's picturesque waterfront for a picnic!

7. App's Pizza

This quaint locale crafts pizzas and calzones from dough and sauce made from all-natural ingredients. The owners have been creating incredible food with Italian and Florida-inspired roots since the early 1970s.

Toppings are simple but of the highest quality and the freshest in town. If you're craving fresh ricotta and tangy tomatoes, App's Pizza has you covered.

Be sure to try their appetizers—from popcorn shrimp to fried mushrooms—and famous sub sandwiches while you're there, too.

8. Uno Pizzeria & Grill

Legend has it that Uno Pizzeria is the best pizza shop in Kissimmee for those longing for Chicago deep-dish. They take the best Italian ingredients and combine them with Chicago pie-making techniques. What comes out of the oven is a pizza to remember.

Uno chefs make their dough fresh daily using a recipe specially designed to give their pizza its signature deep-dish crust (though they also do Chicago thin-crust, too). Toppings include things like pepperoni, plum tomatoes, banana peppers—and, of course, all the cheeses!

Gluten-free diners are well taken care of with food and even beer options. There are also top-class burgers, pasta, soups, salads, and more for those not feeling the pizza.

9. Pienezza Pizza

Pienezza Pizza has a sign on the wall of its restaurant that says, "The best pizza is the one we share." And we couldn't agree more!

With its birthplace in the Italian community in New York, the act of coming together as a family to share food is at the heart of this restaurant. And their pies reflect this heritage, with names like Hey Brooklyn, NY White Pie, and Mama's Lasagne

If anyone in your party isn't into pizza, there are plenty of other options, from signature Big Fat Sandwiches and house pasta to tasty salads.

Uncovering the Best Pizza Shop in Kissimmee

Finding a quality pizza shop can be a challenge no matter what city you're in. Thankfully, Kissimmee is home to some of the best pizza makers in the state, offering everything from crispy wood-fired, thin-crust pizzas to authentic Chicago deep dish pies and New York slices.

Bella Roma is a proudly family-owned and operated pizzeria. And that means sitting down to eat at Bella Roma is like joining a family gathering. Not only that, but we use only the freshest ingredients and handmade pizza dough made daily to craft our award-winning pizzas.

Call us to book a table or order takeout online.

Other Posts

Pizza gourmet

Gas vs Wood Fired Pizza: A Crust-to-Crust Pizza Showdown

In the battle of gas vs wood fired pizza, which pizza cooking method reigns supreme? We're putting them crust-to-crust in this pizza showdown.
Read more
pasta image

Italian Catering: What Are the Nation's Most Popular Italian Meals?

Italian catering remains one of the nation's favorite cuisines. But which meals are the most popular? Find out what's on the menu here.
Read more
pizza base

What to Look for in an Incredible Pizza Base

The pizza base is the start to any great pizza, however, these can often go wrong. Here's what to look for in a great pizza base and how to choose one.
Read more